課程資訊
課程名稱
國際環境法專題研究二
Seminar on International Environmental Law(Ⅱ) 
開課學期
112-2 
授課對象
法律學院  法律研究所  
授課教師
張文貞 
課號
LAW7449 
課程識別碼
A21EM9720 
班次
 
學分
2.0 
全/半年
半年 
必/選修
選修 
上課時間
星期一8,9(15:30~17:20) 
上課地點
 
備註
本課程以英語授課。教室:霖研六1703。與瑪迪安合授
限碩士班以上
總人數上限:34人
外系人數限制:10人 
 
課程簡介影片
 
核心能力關聯
核心能力與課程規劃關聯圖
課程大綱
為確保您我的權利,請尊重智慧財產權及不得非法影印
課程概述

Beginning in the 1960s and 1970s, governments began to realize the importance of protecting the world around us. While certain conservation-related conventions existed before that time, it was in this period that the world truly woke up to environmental degradation and species loss. In these early days, conservation efforts often focused on specific habitats and species, with treaties such as the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species entering into force in 1975, the Convention on Migratory Species entering into force in 1983, and the Wetlands of International Importance Especially as Waterfowl Habitat (Ramsar Convention) entering into force in 1975.

However, the effectiveness of focusing on species and habitats has been fiercely debated. By the 1990s, many scientists and academics began to spot holes in the protections provided. This eventually led to a different approach to international conservation, one in which biodiversity writ large became the focus. Following the Rio Earth Summit, the Convention on Biological Diversity entered into force in 1993, with the goal of promoting the conservation and sustainable use of biological diversity while ensuring its benefits were shared around the globe.

This course will analyze these conventions, and others, engaging students in discussions on their development and effectiveness. The course will further focus on how biodiversity protections have developed through litigation, both in international and domestic fora. Through readings, papers, and discussion, students will critically analyze the network of diverse global actors shaping the conservation of biodiversity around the world.  

課程目標
This course is designed for students in the Master's program of the Law School.

🔥🔥Undergraduate or exchange students who are interested in taking the course for credit are certainly welcome, and will receive authorization codes for taking the course if coming to the first class on 19 February 2024.

The course aims to achieve the following three objectives:

1. Increase awareness and understanding of international law.

Our course takes a global perspective, aiming to enhance student awareness of the international biodiversity regime within the context of globalization. Contemporary international norms are evolving in a globalized context. Students not only need to comprehend this trend but also understand how diverse actors influence and shape the content of international law related to biodiversity issues.

2. Integrate existing relevant research from domestic and international sources through course literature.

The assigned readings for this course include academic writings as well as litigation documents from international and domestic adjudications. Throughout the course, students are expected to both grapple with existing literature and integrate relevant research in discussions.

3. Combine research resources at NTU Law to promote related research.

Our course aims to not only understand the content of international biodiversity law but also to integrate student work with the existing research resources of the Law School. In 2009, NTU Law School established the "Policy and Law Center for Environmental Sustainability (PLES)," a research center devoted to examining environmental law. Ultimately, this course aims to inspire students to engage with research related to the preservation of biodiversity and begin developing their own research questions.  
課程要求
This course places significant emphasis on active class discussions and participation. You are required to read assigned materials before each class and actively participate in course discussions.

• Class Participation: Students will be evaluated on their preparation for and engagement in class. Students are expected to complete all required reading ahead of the relevant class period. Students are further encouraged to at least review the recommended materials.

You can find the reading materials here: https://cool.ntu.edu.tw/courses/34214/modules

• Mock Negotiation: Students will be assigned a role in the Mock Negotiation. Students are responsible for preparing a short 1-page write up per team ahead of the mock negotiation, specifying (1) key goals of their role (2) negotiating strategy and (3) expected biggest obstacle in the negotiation. You should do additional research beyond the provided materials to understand your role’s position and advocacy interests.

o Following the negotiation, students should expand their negotiation strategy memo to include a reflection on the mock negotiation. This memorandum should be at least 2000 words.

• Case Analysis and Presentation: Students will select a piece of litigation to analyze and present on.

o Case presentations should outline key facts of the case, include a discussion of the cases’ role in protecting biodiversity, and include at least 3 discussion questions for the class. Presentations should be 10-15 minutes, followed by a class discussion on the case, in which the presenter should take a leading role.

o Case analyses will be due the final day of class and should be at least 4000 words. Analyses should include (1) an outline of the case, detailing the arguments of the parties, judgement, etc. and (2) a critical examination of the litigation and how it fits into international biodiversity law.  
預期每週課後學習時數
 
Office Hours
另約時間 
指定閱讀
1. David Hunter et al., International Environmental Law and Policy (Foundation Press, 6th ed. 2022).
2. Guillaume Futhazar et al., Biodiversity Litigation (Oxford Univ. Press 2022).
3. Selected Cases & Materials
* All selected cases and reference materials for the course will be placed on the course website. 
參考書目
 
評量方式
(僅供參考)
   
針對學生困難提供學生調整方式
 
上課形式
作業繳交方式
考試形式
其他
由師生雙方議定
課程進度
週次
日期
單元主題
第1週
February 19, 2024  Contents:

• Introductions
• Course description and administrative matters
• Discussion of root causes of biodiversity loss

Readings:

# Required:
Video appreciation
o What is Biodiversity? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6Ua_zWDH6U
o Taiwan’s Nature Reserves Valued at US $2Billion https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuM_o5Wiq4E

o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 1, pp. 8-10, 12-15
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 15, pp. 976-988
o Biodiversity Litigation, Ch. 1, pp. 1-8

* Recommended:
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 1, pp. 3-7, 25-37
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 2, pp. 42-95
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 15, pp. 988-996
o Alliance for Zero Extinction: https://zeroextinction.org
o IUCN Green List: https://iucngreenlist.org
o IUCN Red List: https://www.iucnredlist.org
o The Insect Apocalypse Is Here, N.Y. Times, Nov. 27, 2018, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/27/magazine/insect-apocalypse.html?searchResultPosition=1.
 
第2週
February 26, 2024   Contents:

• Standardization and development of international environmental issues
• The debate on the validity of international norms and the research orientation of international law
• Key principles and concepts of international environmental law

Readings:

# Required:
o Yeh Jiunn-rong, Chapter 3 "Standardization and Timeliness of Global Environmental Issues", Global Environmental Issues: Taiwan's Perspective, Juliu Books, 1999, pp. 43-58.
o Yeh Juinn-rong, Chapter 4 "Development Trends and Impacts of Global Environmental Issues", Global Environmental Issues: Taiwan's Perspective, Juliu Books, 1999, pp. 59-71.
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 8, pp. 421-481 (read description of each principle, can skip questions and document excerpts)

* Recommended:
o Oona A. Hathaway & Harold Hongju Koh eds., Foundations of International Law and Politics (Foundation Press, 2005), pp 26-47, 112-135, 135-173, 173-204
 
第3週
March 4, 2024  Contents:

• Development of international biodiversity law – from species-based governance to a biodiversity focus
• Key convention structures in biodiversity governance
• Overview of CITES and CMS

Readings:

# Required:
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 15, pp. 1082-1100
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 15, pp. 1048-1053

* Recommended:
o Sands, 'International protection of endangered species in the face of wildlife trade: whither conservation diplomacy?' (2017) 20(1) Asia Pacific Journal of International Law 5
o Caddell, Richard. "International Law and the Protection of Migratory Wildlife: An Appraisal of Twenty Five Years of the Bonn Convention." Colorado Journal of Environmental Law and Policy 16 (2005): 113-156.
o Anderson, R. S. (1995). The Lacey Act: America's Premier Weapon in the Fight Against Unlawful Wildlife Trafficking. Pub. Land L. Rev., 16, 27.
o 葉俊榮(1994)。〈華盛頓公約與瀕臨絕種動植物的保護-台灣面臨全球環境議題的挑戰與因應系列(一)〉,《律師通訊》、172期,頁:76-82。
o Abensperg-Traun, M. (2009). CITES, sustainable use of wild species and incentive-driven conservation in developing countries, with an emphasis on southern Africa. Biological Conservation, 142(5), 948-963.
o Heng Lye and Yang, "Illegal Trade in Endangered Forest and Marine Species – Enhancing Laws and Enforcement: A Southeast Asian Perspective," in Protecting Forest and Marine Biodiversity: The Role of Law" (ed. E. Couzens et al.) (2017)
 
第4週
March 11, 2024  Contents:

• Development of international biodiversity law – from species-based governance to a biodiversity focus
• Key convention structures in biodiversity governance
• Overview of CBD
• Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework

Readings:

# Required:
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 15, pp. 996-1010
o Biodiversity Litigation, Ch. 1, pp. 8-12
o WWF, "One year after the adoption of the landmark Global Biodiversity Framework, are countries on track to deliver on their promise to reverse biodiversity loss?" (2023), available at https://wwf.panda.org/wwf_news/?10459966/One-year-after-the-adoption-of-the-landmark-Global-Biodiversity-Framework-are-countries-on-track-to-deliver-on-their-promise-to-reverse-biodiversity-loss.

* Recommended:
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 15, pp. 1039-1047
o Morgera, E., & Tsioumani, E. (2011). Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow: Looking Afresh at the Convention on Biological Diversity. Yearbook of International Environmental Law, 21(1), 3-40.
o New York Times, "Nearly Every Country Signs On to a Sweeping Deal to Protect Nature" (2022-12-19), available at
o Panjabi, Ranee K.L. (1993). International Law and the Preservation of Species: An Analysis of the Convention on Biological Diversity Signed at the Rio Earth Summit in 1992. Penn State Intl L. Rev.,11,2.
o Kal Raustiala. (1997). Domestic Institutions and International Regulatory Cooperation: Comparative Responses to the Convention on Biological Diversity. World Politics, 49,4.
o Streck, Charlotte, "Synergies between the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework and the Paris Agreement: the role of policy milestones, monitoring frameworks and safeguards," 23 Climate Policy 6 (2023).  
第5週
March 18, 2024  Contents:

• Protection of habitat—UNESCO, Ramsar, UNCLOS
• Recent developments: Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction Treaty (High Seas Treaty) under UNCLOS

Readings:

# Required:
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 16, pp. 1144-1148, 1153-1159
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch.12, pp. 730-737, 780-783
o Reuters, “Changing Tides” (2023-03-30), available at

* Recommended:
o Bridgewater, P., Kim, R., (2021). The Ramsar Convention on Wetlands at 50. 5 Nature Ecology & Evolution 3, 268-270.
o Melubo, K., Lovelock, B., (2019). Living Inside a UNESCO World Heritage Site: The Perspective of the Maasai Community in Tanzania. Tourism Planning and Development. (link)
o Mossop, Joanna. "Can We Make the Oceans Greener? The Successes and Failures of UNCLOS as an Environmental Treaty." 49 VUWLR 4 (2019)
o 李佩蓉,《國際捕鯨管制公約》的變遷與停滯——跨國規範化歷程的關鍵因素分析,中研院法學期刊,202203 (30期)
o Icelandic Fisheries Case (United Kingdom v. Iceland), 1974 I.C.J. 3 (1974)
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 12, pp. 775-780
 
第6週
March 25, 2024  Contents:

• Introduction of Mock Negotiation activity
• Discussion of forest protections
• Team preparations for Week 7 activity

Readings:

# Required:
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 16, pp. 1161-1173, 1175-1179, 1184-1187
o Mock Negotiation materials
 
第7週
April 1, 2023  Contents:

• Mock Negotiation

Readings:
• Prepare for Mock Negotiation
• 1-page strategy memorandum due before 11:59 PM on March 31st
 
第8週
April 8, 2023  Contents:

• Overview of biodiversity litigation
• Learnings from climate change litigation
Readings:

# Required:
o Biodiversity Litigation, Ch. 1, pp. 14-16
o Biodiversity Litigation, Ch. 13, pp. 364-367
o Rodriguez-Garavito, C., and Boyd, D. "A Rights Turn in Biodiversity Litigation?" 12 Transnational Environmental Law 3 (2023): 498-536.

* Recommended:
o Biodiversity Litigation, Ch. 1, pp. 16-26
o J. Peel & H.M. Osofsky, ‘A Rights Turn in Climate Change Litigation?’ (2018) 7(1) Transnational Environmental Law, pp. 37–67
o J. Phelps, et al., “Environmental liability litigation could remedy biodiversity loss” Conservation Letters (2021).
o Z. Rong, “Using Environmental Litigation to Advance Ecological Restoration under the Convention on Biological Diversity in China” Chinese Journal of Environmental Law (2023).  
第9週
April 15, 2023  Contents:

• Biodiversity litigation before the ICJ
• Student case presentations

# Required:
o Relevant case documents

* Recommended:
o International Environmental Law and Policy, Ch. 15, pp. 1057-1075
o Dr. Jorge E. Viñuales, The Contribution of the International Court of Justice to the Development of International Environmental Law: A Contemporary Assessment, 32 Fordham Int'l L.J. 232 (2008).
o Biodiversity Litigation, Ch. 12 
第10週
April 22, 2023  Contents:

• Legal personhood for nature
• Student case presentations

Readings:

• Required:

# Relevant case documents

* Recommended:
o Constitucion De La Republica Del Ecuador Decreto Legislativo 0, Registro Oficial 449 de 20 October 2008, Ultima modification: 13 July 2011, Art 71
o Guillaume Chapron, Yaffa Epstein, and Jose Vicente Lopez- Bao, A Rights Revolution for Nature: Introduction of Legal Rights for Nature could Protect Natural Systems from Destruction, (2016) 363 Science 1392
o Christopher Rodgers, A New Approach to Protecting Ecosystems: The Te Awa Tupua (Whanganui River Claims Settlement) Act 2017 (2017) 19 Environmental Law Review 266
o Saskia Stucki, Towards a Theory of Legal Animal Rights: Simple and Fundamental Rights (2020) 40 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 533. 
第11週
April 29, 2023  Contents:

• Species biodiversity
• Student case presentations

Readings:

# Required:
o Relevant case documents

* Recommended:
o Doyle, Michael, and Pamela King. "How the courthouse came to be a major habitat for the ESA." E&E News (June 20, 2023). [https://www.eenews.net/articles/how-the-courthouse-came-to-be-a-major-habitat-for-the-esa/]
o Biber, E. and Brosi, B. "Officious Intermeddlers or Citizen Experts? Petitions and Public Production of Information in Environmental Law." 58 UCLA Law Review 321 (2010) (link)
o Department of Justice, "Gibson Guitar Corp. Agrees to Resolve Investigation into Lacey Act Violations" (August 6, 2012),  
第12週
May 6, 2024  Contents:

• Biodiversity and the human right to a healthy environment
• Student case presentations

Readings:

# Required:
o Relevant case documents

* Recommended:
o Resolution of the UN Human Rights Council 48/ 13, The Human Right to a Safe, Clean, Healthy and Sustainable Environment (18 October 2021).
o UNHRC, ‘Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Issue of Human Rights Obligations relating to the Enjoyment of a Safe, Clean, Healthy and Sustainable Environment’, 19 Jan. 2017, UN Doc. A/HRC/34/49,
o Ituarte-Lima, Claudia. (2023). “Biosphere Defenders Leveraging the Human Right to Healthy Environment for Transformative Change.” 53 Environmental Policy and Law.  
第13週
May 13, 2024  Contents:

• Biodiversity and development projects
• Student case presentations

Readings:

# Required:
o Relevant case documents

* Recommended:
o James Thuo Gathii, ‘Saving the Serengenti: Africa’s New International Judicial Environmentalism’ (2014) 16 Chicago Journal of International Law 386
o Kathryn McCallum, “Changing Landscapes: Enforcing Environmental Laws in China through Public Interest Litigation” (2017) 20 Asia Pacific Journal of Environmental Law.  
第14週
May 20, 2024   Contents:

• Biodiversity and climate change
• Student case presentations

Readings:

# Required:
o Relevant case documents

* Recommended:
o Glinski, Carola. "Transfer of Climate Litigation to Biodiversity Protection?" 10 European Journal of Comparative Law and Governance (2023): 416-437.
o Hodas, David, Biodiversity and Climate Change Laws: A Failure to Communicate? (June 12, 2008). Biodiversity Conservation, Law, & Livelihoods: Bridging the North South Divide, Cambridge University Press, 2008.
o Paola Andrea Acosta Alvarado, Daniel Rivas-Ramírez. “A Milestone in Environmental and Future Generations’ Rights Protection: Recent Legal Developments before the Colombian Supreme Court”, 30 J. Envtl. L. 3 (2018). 
第15週
May 27, 2024  Contents:
• Final discussions on key themes in biodiversity governance
• Where do we go from here?

Readings:

# Required:
o TBD

* Recommended:
o Sherkow, J., Greely, H. “What if Extinction is Not Forever.” 340 Science (2013). (link)
o Katz, B. “California Condor Nearly Went Extinct. Now, the 1000th Chick of a Recovery Program Has Hatched,” Smithsonian Magazine (2019). (link)
o Robert Kunzig, Is Focusing on "Hot Spots" the Key to Preserving Biodiversity?, Scientific American (link)
o Rewilding Europe: https://rewildingeurope.com/
o Revive & Restore: https://reviverestore.org/projects/woolly-mammoth/